Billy Opens Up About D’arcy: “We Both Looked Bad”
Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan is opening up again about the band’s most complicated relationship, his longtime bassist and original bandmate D’arcy Wretzky.
In a new Substack video, Corgan reflects on her contributions with an unusually soft, conciliatory tone. He acknowledges that the fallout surrounding the 2018 reunion, which reunited the classic Pumpkins lineup without D’arcy, “didn’t leave either one of us in the best light.”
For newer fans, the tension between Corgan and Wretzky goes back decades. D’arcy was a founding member in 1988 and played an essential role through the band’s most iconic era…Gimese Dream, and Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. Behind the scenes, their relationship was often strained, marked by creative clashes, personal struggles, and long periods of miscommunication.
Wretzky left the band in 1999 before the release of “Machina/The Machines of God,” and after that, she withdrew almost entirely from public life.
But in this new video, Corgan seems intent on giving her the overdue credit she deserves.
He praises her intuition, saying that D’arcy had a unique ability to influence the band’s musical direction and emotional balance — something he now recognizes as a critical part of the Pumpkins’ classic chemistry. He even says the original lineup’s dynamic was “irreplaceable” in shaping their biggest albums.
While it doesn’t sound like a reunion is suddenly happening, Corgan’s tone suggests a softening — maybe even a bridge being rebuilt after years of distance.
For longtime fans of the original four, this feels like a rare moment of honesty… and maybe a hint that the story isn’t completely over.